How to choose an M&A advisor
A 10-point checklist for owners selling a business. Each point comes with the question to ask the advisor.
Quick Answer
Choose an M&A advisor by checking ten things: deal-size fit, industry experience, who works on your deal, how the process runs, the fee structure, the size of the buyer list, references, the length of the tail, communication and confidentiality. Ask each advisor the same ten questions and write down the answers. Then compare the written answers, since the pitch meeting is where every firm sounds good. Talk to at least three firms. Use a matching service to get introductions, and use the checklist below to decide among the firms you meet.
The 10-Point Checklist
- Deal-size fit. Advisors and brokers serve different sizes of business. Our guide to business brokers vs M&A advisors explains where the line sits. Ask them this: what size of deal do you usually close, and where does mine fall in that range?
- Industry experience. A firm that has sold companies like yours already knows the buyers and the usual objections. Ask them this: which companies in my industry have you sold, and who bought them?
- Who does the work. The partner who pitches you may not be the person who runs your process. Ask them this: who will be on my deal day to day, and how many other deals will they be running?
- The process. A managed process approaches a curated list of qualified buyers, and a listing waits for inbound interest. Ask them this: walk me through the first 90 days, step by step.
- The fee structure. Fees come in a few shapes, from a straight commission to a retainer plus a success fee to success-only. Our fee comparison sets them side by side. Ask them this: what exactly will I pay, and when, if the deal closes and if it does not?
- Retainer credit and minimums. Some firms credit the retainer against the success fee and some do not. Ask them this: is the retainer credited at closing, and is there a minimum success fee?
- Buyer reach. A competitive process needs several qualified buyers at the table. Ask them this: how many buyers will you approach for a business like mine, and how do you choose them?
- References. Past clients tell you what a pitch deck cannot. Ask them this: can I speak with two owners you sold for in the last two years, including one whose deal was difficult?
- The tail. An engagement letter can entitle the advisor to a fee if you sell to a buyer they contacted after the engagement ends. Our M&A advisory fees guide says a 12 to 18 month tail is reasonable and a 36-month tail is not. Ask them this: how long does the tail run, and which buyers does it cover?
- Communication and confidentiality. You want regular updates and a plan for keeping your name out of the market until you approve it. Ask them this: how often will I hear from you, and who sees my company name before I sign an NDA?
Understanding The Fees
The fee question trips up more owners than any other, so it is worth a closer look. On our broker and advisor fee comparison, a business broker's straight commission is indicatively in the 8 to 12% range for small businesses. The same page describes the Lehman formula, a declining scale that many advisors use for the success fee. Our fees guide lists the original version as 5% on the first $1 million, 4% on the second, 3% on the third, 2% on the fourth and 1% above $4 million. Many firms use scaled-up versions of it, so treat these figures as orientation and get each firm's own numbers in writing before you compare.
How To Run The Comparison
Send the same short brief to every firm before the first call: your industry, a rough revenue and profit range, your timeline and what you want your role to be after the sale. Then ask the ten questions in the same order each time. Put the answers in one sheet with a column for each firm, and leave a cell blank when the firm did not answer. A blank cell is a question to ask on the first call. Ask for the fee structure and the engagement letter in writing, and read the scope section line by line. The firm that answers all ten clearly, and shows you on paper the same number it gave you on the phone, is the one to meet a second time.
Red Flags
- A fee proposal that is vague about scope, with no stated number of buyers contacted or materials produced.
- A very long tail period after the engagement ends.
- No cap on reimbursable expenses.
- A retainer that is not credited against the success fee on a small deal, which can push total fees up sharply.
- Pressure to sign before you have spoken to other firms.
- References offered only from the firm's best deal.
The first four come from the red-flag list in our M&A advisory fees guide. The last two come from how owners tend to be rushed, and we could not tie them to a figure, so weigh them as judgment.
Where Matching Services Fit
A matching service introduces you to firms, and the ten checks above still decide which one you hire. ProCloser is one example: it is free to sellers, matches an owner with one or two vetted advisory firms, keeps every introduction NDA-first and starts with an M&A Matching Sync intro call. Some firms in the network work success-only with no retainer. For a comparison with other free services, read Axial Advisor Finder vs They Got Acquired vs ProCloser. For the full selling process, start with how to sell your business.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many M&A advisors should I talk to?
Talk to at least three. Our M&A advisory fees guide recommends getting proposals from at least three firms, because it shows you the market rate for your deal size and gives you room to negotiate. Ask all three the same ten questions and compare the written answers side by side.
Is a lower fee always better?
No, because a low headline percentage can hide a long tail, a minimum fee or an uncredited retainer, so compare the total you would pay whether or not the deal closes, along with how many buyers the firm contacts and what materials it produces.
What is a no-retainer M&A advisor?
A no-retainer advisor charges nothing upfront and is paid only when your deal closes. That removes the upfront cost and aligns the advisor with getting you to a sale. Some firms in the ProCloser network work this way, and others run a retained process for larger or more complex deals.
When should I choose a broker instead of an M&A advisor?
Brokers usually fit smaller, owner-operated businesses likely to sell to an individual or local buyer. M&A advisors usually fit lower-middle-market companies and up, with several types of credible buyers. Our business broker vs M&A advisor guide covers the middle range, where either can work.
Does a matching service replace my own checks?
No. A matching service introduces you to firms, and you still need to check deal-size fit, industry experience, references and the engagement letter. Treat the introduction as a starting list and use the ten-point checklist above to decide among the firms you meet.
Start with a short list of vetted firms.
Tell us about your business and we will match you with one or two vetted advisory firms, NDA-first. Free to sellers. Confidential.
Aaron founded ProCloser.ai and reviews every guide on this site against the firm's deal data and advisor research. This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Get matched free.